Embracing Failure In Design Thinking Education: The Path To Innovation

Conor De Courcey, Head of Design and Technology, Tanglin Trust School

In the world of design education, failure is not merely an option; it is an essential component of the learning journey. Teaching students to embrace failure within the design thinking framework fosters innovation, creativity, and critical problem-solving skills. By encouraging the exploration of diverse solutions to a problem, we prepare students to think critically and develop unique products that reflect their individual perspectives.

The Importance of Failure

Design is fundamentally about creating solutions to real-world problems through exploration and experimentation. In a classroom setting, each student should strive to approach a problem in their own unique way. This diversity of thought is a catalyst for innovation. When we encourage students to view failure positively, we enable them to extract invaluable lessons that enrich the design process.

Take prototyping as an example. Creating models allows students to visualize their ideas and identify potential failures before they escalate into costly time-consuming mistakes. The question every design student should continue to ask is, “Why do I need to make this model?” This inquiry promotes iterative thinking, where each unsuccessful attempt becomes a stepping stone towards a refined solution. Throughout this process, students often uncover issues they had not initially recognised, leading to innovative breakthroughs and a deeper understanding of design.

"In the world of design education, failure is not merely an option; it is an essential component of the learning journey. Each unsuccessful attempt becomes a stepping stone towards a refined solution"

Challenges in Teaching Failure

Integrating a culture of failure into design education presents its own challenges, particularly in secondary education. Here are some common obstacles educators can encounter:

1. Time Constraints: Design projects can be time-intensive, and the iterative process of failure and refinement demands substantial classroom time, which is often limited by curriculum requirements and timetabling. Emphasising problem-solving over the need for a polished final prototype can provide a way to overcome this.

2. Perceptions of Failure: It can be difficult to help students internalise that failure is a necessary part of the learning process, especially if they have been conditioned to see failure as a setback. A practical approach is to model examples of this; I often create prototypes with design flaws and invite students to collaborate on ways to improve them.

3. Balancing Support: Educators must strike the right balance between offering guidance and encouraging students to tackle challenges independently. Understanding each student’s strengths is crucial in this regard; I recommend curating a bank of helpful tutorials that students can access, allowing them to seek independence while still receiving support.

4. Skill Development: A foundational knowledge of manufacturing and design is essential for students to effectively engage in complex design thinking challenges. Crafting a curriculum that covers these skills before delving into design thinking allows students the confidence to take risks in problem-solving.

Implementing a Successful Curriculum

At Tanglin Trust School, we have proactively addressed these challenges by developing a curriculum that equips students with the necessary skills while fostering a culture of innovation. By introducing, focused design thinking challenges at the beginning of lessons—such as “How many ways can I bend this shape to hold a stylus?”—we encourage students to experiment and take risks within a manageable timeframe. Using CAD software provides an excellent opportunity to test students’ resilience; a five-minute challenge to create a uniquely dimensioned shape often results in a wide range of failures and successes.

Each challenge builds confidence and encourages students to embrace the unknown. This approach not only promotes creative thinking but also cultivates an environment where failure is regarded as a valuable part of the learning experience. Consequently, we have seen students from Year 7 to Year 13 develop a variety of unique products, often leading to unexpected innovations.

Moreover, we have invited external companies into our classrooms to set our design briefs, this real-world application motivates and brings the best out of each student knowing their ideas go beyond the walls of the classroom.

The Rewards of Embracing Failure The benefits of teaching students to embrace failure in design thinking are profound. Students cultivate resilience, adaptability, and perseverance—qualities that extend beyond design and into all aspects of life. By nurturing an environment where failure is viewed as acceptable, we prepare our students to tackle future challenges, equipping them with the tools necessary for innovation and success.

While the journey of integrating failure into design education poses challenges, the rewards of cultivating creativity and innovation in our students far outweigh the difficulties. By allowing students to fail, we empower them to think freely, solve problems creatively, and ultimately become the innovators of tomorrow.

Test